Opps! Looks like I got lucky with that deadline extension. Sorry.
I plan to leave comments on each individual game in the
Review Contest thread. I already previously wrote a review of Dragons!
and extensive feedback for Troll Over though probably won't write
many other full-length reviews.
In the end I decided not to following the example rating scale much
and instead ranked each game against each other, which was pretty hard to do.
There's vast differences in quality between some of these games, yet
a rather small range in how much fun I had playing them.
Troll Over 7
The Pumpkin Warriors 5
You're lucky I decided to replay this one because there had been a bunch of
updates since I first played it. I got far further this time,
past the first dungeon, and saw there was much more to the game.
Winged Realm 8
Invasion of the Mantle Dwellers 5
Note 2: On seeing what it's doing to Dragons!, I'm beginning to think the 2/3 rule in its current form is a bad idea. I think next time, the rule will substitute the most common score to represent missing votes rather than simply subbing with automatic fives.
Most common score for that game? There is very little difference between that and just ranking all games by their average scores.