2. The game doesn't have ripped graphics, material or characters in it.
"Material?" Does that mean music/sound effects (...which disqualifies a
huge portion of OHR games... especially in the case of music... though sound effects not so much anymore thanks to SFXR!), or what? I mean, I suppose the possibility of a ripped font is out there too, but that doesn't seem like it would stand out as much as music or especially graphics would.
And for "ripped characters" I'm guessing you mean fangame type situations (the only recent examples of fangames or fangame-like things that immediately come to mind are Batman & Robin, Village People, Puckamon, and I think a couple of Mario games, though I remember there being more of them years ago... It seems like there aren't a lot of OHR fangames being made anymore, from what I've seen) are probably not good for something like this, rather than
any reference to characters from other series.
I know the topic of "how safe are parodies of famous characters" came up before (when I was asked about porting Okédoké to OUYA and smartphones) and it seemed like the consensus was that obvious parodies (like Cap'n Crunch being a gang boss in Okédoké, or for an older example, Barney showing up as a giant demonic boss monster in Monterey Penguin) were probably okay. Fangames on the other hand, I know some of them (not OHR ones as far as I'm aware, but fangames in general) have definitely gotten in trouble with the makers of the original game in the past.
====
But yeah, this definitely seems like the sort of thing that would work better for "short, but complete and well-made" games rather than huge sprawling RPGs. Maybe it should include one or two "bigger RPGs" (Dungeonmen? maybe Vikings if it's finished?) and then a bunch of smaller games of various genres--at least one platformer, one puzzly game, one "shorter/weirder RPG" (maybe Baconthulhu could be this one, being roguelike-esque), and so on.
Oh, and Okédoké has an almost entirely ripped soundtrack (I think the title screen theme is safe, being an actual Mexican folk song if I'm remembering right, so it's probably public domain; there's also a couple of other songs that were things people uploaded as "free-to-use-if-you-give-credit" music... other than that, all ripped, though), so I figure it's not really the kind of thing you're looking for for this.